Juri rightly, in my mind, points out that Union soldiers did not begin fighting the war to end slavery but that, by the end of the war, there had been a definitive shift in their reasons for fighting due to their experiences in the war. Union soldiers may have started out ambivalent about slavery and fought for more abstract ideals such as liberty and a free nation, but, by the end of the war, the vast majority of Union troops were as committed to abolishing slavery as they were to winning the war. Soldiers’ experiences during the war, particularly their interactions with and perceptions of women, were hugely influential in changing these attitudes. As Manning states,
“Yet more influential than Union soldiers’ preexisting notions, or even their firsthand observations of the South, were their interactions with actual slaves, which led many to view slavery as a dehumanizing and evil institution that corroded the moral virtue necessary for a population to govern itself.” (49)
At the beginning of the war, when Union soldiers set foot in the South—some for the first time—they were shocked by the treatment and position of women in Southern society. According to Manning, women were the moral barometer by which a society could be measured, and perceptions of women and women’s behavior during the Civil War, greatly affected the Union’s understandings of Southern society and, ultimately, their views on slavery. At the time, civilized women were expected to remain confined to the indoors, and when Union soldiers saw women—even slaves—in the fields hoeing and plowing, they were shocked. (72) Interactions with white women, as well as incidents such as those in New Orleans, further solidified Northern soldiers’ convictions that slavery was corrupting Southern society. While soldiers were becoming increasingly convinced that slavery was a significant cause of the war and a problem that would have be to be dealt with at the war’s end, they were still ambivalent about how best to respond to slavery.
Nearly four years later, in the time following Lincoln’s reelection in 1864, though, attitudes towards slavery were much more solidified. By this time, the Emancipation Proclamation had been in effect for over a year and Union soldiers had witnessed the bravery of black troops. The seemingly miraculous success of the Union in battles such as Vicksburg and Gettysburg had convinced soldiers not only that slavery was an evil that must end but that blacks deserved some, if not all, of the equal rights afforded white men, such as suffrage, equal pay, and legal equality. (219) Thus, soldiers’ thinking during the war regarding slavery and African Americans had shifted from one in which slavery was seen as an evil corrupting society to the belief that blacks should not just be free, but that they should enjoy civil rights. While this was not the belief held by everyone, Manning says
“A critical mass of white Union troops supported expanded rights for African Americans, and believed that the U.S. government had a duty to work toward equality for black citizens.” (193)
While there was still a century’s worth of work to be done before complete equality was fully realized between blacks and whites, Manning’s book shows the dramatic shift that did take place in soldiers’ attitudes towards slavery and African Americans from the beginning of the war in 1861 to its conclusion in 1865.